Rebellion and Inheritance: A Study of Film Archetypes in Contemporary Chinese New Generation Directors’ Creations

Research Article
Open access

Rebellion and Inheritance: A Study of Film Archetypes in Contemporary Chinese New Generation Directors’ Creations

Fei Xue 1*
  • 1 Peking University, Beijing, China    
  • *corresponding author rara481846778@gmail.com
Published on 5 December 2024 | https://doi.org/10.54254/2753-7080/2024.18130
AHR Vol.10
ISSN (Print): 2753-7099
ISSN (Online): 2753-7080

Abstract

This essay explores the two notions of emancipation and inheritance in the films of recent Chinese new generation filmmakers by exploring their revisionist revisement of old film stereotypes in order to capture modern Chinese society. This liberation from linear structure, scripted character design and sterile editing makes these filmmakers have a distinct cinematic syntax for existential uncertainty, personal aspiration and uncompromising realism. Meanwhile, they take on and recycle old themes, symbols and narrative structures, weaving cultural continuity into contemporary retellings. This dissertation delved into films like Kaili Blues, Ash Is Purest White and The Piano in a Factory to see how filmmakers of the new generation are capable of balancing innovation with homage in order to bring viewers films that are culturally and globally sensitive. In this essay, I want to reveal how these filmmakers have kept the identity of Chinese cinema alive while working with contemporary narrative challenges, making Chinese cinema a force to reckon with on a world stage.

Keywords:

Chinese cinema, new generation directors, cinematic rebellion, cultural inheritance, film archetypes

Xue,F. (2024). Rebellion and Inheritance: A Study of Film Archetypes in Contemporary Chinese New Generation Directors’ Creations. Advances in Humanities Research,10,19-22.
Export citation

1 Introduction

Chinese film’s new-gen directors are revolutionising the genre by breaking the moulds of narrative form, character design and visual style – quite different from the Confucian and socialist realist roots of Chinese cinema [1]. Classical Chinese film generally stayed with linear story lines that featured straightforward moral endings, and tended to cast loyal, pious and civic characters. These characters and narratives were not just story ideas, but symbols of culture and politics that reinforced communal values and solidarity. But the filmmakers of today are breaking out of those moulds and using nonlinear plotlines, episodic storylines and morally grey characters, all to create a complex and nuanced image of human life. This movement is being spearheaded by directors like Bi Gan, Jia Zhangke and Lou Ye, who make films exploring the existential crises and cultural revolutions of a modern China that is rapidly modernising. In applying these new strategies, they provide a more personal, more human vision of what happens to Chinese people, the contradictions, hope and uncertainty of contemporary life. Meanwhile, these filmmakers are as intuned as ever with the history of Chinese film – old themes, symbolism and narrative modes that stay in synch with their cinematic predecessors. Through this combination of dissent and piety, these filmmakers produce for both Chinese and foreign audiences while keeping the spirit of Chinese culture alive but appealing to a wide range of audiences [2]. This essay will focus on the new generation directors in how they operate through this dualities, and how they have established Chinese cinema as a vibrant and dynamic voice of international cinema.

2 The Concept of Rebellion in New Generation Directors’ Works

2.1 Rebellion Against Conventional Narratives

Chinese filmmakers of the new generation sabotage the mainstream Chinese film system with narrative structures not familiar from mainstream Chinese cinema. Chinese movies had been following a cause-and-effect linear narrative pattern for decades, in which events merely correlated to one another to a morally satisfactory conclusion [3]. These traditional stories were rooted in Confucianism and socialist realism, a belief in morality and community, and were sometimes used to reinforce the public ideal. But contemporary filmmakers are turning away from it, leaning towards non-contained narratives, broken-down scenes and unclear endings that mirror the complexity and volatility of modern existence. Instead of fetishising human life as symmetrical and intelligible, they look into the unresolved uncertainty of reality, capturing the uncertainties of human relations and human conflict. This morphology of narrative also allows directors to create fleshed-out portraits of their characters, depicting psychoanalytic ambiguity and existential crisis in ways that invite viewers into a state of unanswered questions about selfhood, purpose and truth. Bi Gan’s Kaili Blues, for example, takes place between recollections and re-enactments in an almost dreamlike rhythm to match the mood of the main character. Its non-linear narrative and time dislocation also speak to the movement of memory, showing how past and present tangle together in the human mind. And Jia Zhangke’s Ash Is Purest White, also about a woman learning to love and be loyal in the face of betrayal and social calamity, is a novel in which there is no morally explicit conclusion, only identity crises and broken dreams. This rupture with traditional storytelling is reflective of wider cultural change, which mirrors the fragmented, hyperintense landscape of modern China, where people are often caught up in an avalanche of social, economic and political upheaval. Losing the linear narrative formulas of the past, these filmmakers urge viewers to reconsider truth and the nature of human experience, producing films that not only entertain but act as contemplative meditations on the changing Chinese within a globalised world [4].

2.2 Character Archetypes as a Site of Rebellion

Characters in traditional Chinese cinema have tended to be reifications of family orientation, patrioticism and Confucian faith, the ideals of communalism and the primacy of collective good over private self-interest. Such characters, moulded in filial virtues of piety, obedience and citizenship, function as moral models that reinforce the cultural primacy of family loyalty, eldership and national responsibility. This classical portrait matches the Confucian tradition that stresses social harmony over personal ambition and a collectivism that has permeated Chinese cultural history for centuries. Film stars often sacrifice themselves in service of the family or community, living up to ethical ideals in the style of both culture and politics [5]. Yet, the role is also being re-imagined by younger filmmakers, who are creating characters that go against these moulds. Instead of just doing the right thing, these filmmakers create characters with distinctly private desires, moral dilemmas and internal conflicts that contradict the standard notions of rightness. They are no longer monolithic moral avatars but characters facing real life challenges, with underlying motivations, moral contradictions and, often, a willingness to defy the status quo. In doing so, filmmakers of the new generation present a more nuanced, humanized portrait of character that asks people to wonder what the status quo can or cannot stand in a changing world.

Lou Ye’s Summer Palace offers an immediate illustration of this turn, in which its heroes are motivated by a desire for liberty, romance and self-realisation, drives that cannot be accommodated within the confines of convention. In the movie, characters pursue personal fulfilment at the expense of social obligation, so there’s a tension between individual desire and social obligation. This question of self and society finds further expression in Diao Yinan’s The Wild Goose Lake, where the hero, a morally uncertain character, leads a violent, dark underworld life that is less about social obligations and more about survival and freedom. This journey, with its morally dubious choices, illustrates how a transition from collectivism to self-control and self-determination can be as much a part of the new self for Chinese youth today, who are increasingly seeking personal freedom over institutional duties. Such descriptions reflect a wider cultural shift as young people in a rapidly modernising China strive for freedom and individual autonomy against centuries-old norms of collectivism and obedience [6]. When children rewrite character roles in this way, they not only reveal the struggles of personal selfhood in a society steeped in community, but they also allow us to connect with characters that find themselves at a crossroads between tradition and modernity. This reconceptualisation of character archetypes reflects a dramatic change in public attitudes, and a generational shift towards an acceptance of individual choice and responsibility over collective responsibility, part of a larger trend toward individualism in an earlier collectivist culture.

2.3 Cinematic Techniques Reflecting Rebellion

This other rebellion reveals itself in the creative approaches to cinema taken up by the younger generation of filmmakers who deviate from the clean, meticulously scripted aesthetics of classic Chinese cinema. Whereas earlier movies relied on perfectly shot cinematography, naturalistic camera movement and ethereal compositions to render a dreamlike world, today’s filmmakers use something more coarse and less artificial. They favour hand-held shots, natural lighting and ambient noise, and offer an unsharp, unrefined version of contemporary Chinese culture that is quick and real. Handheld cameras and the emphasis on spontaneity help filmmakers such as Zhang Dalei and Wen Muye place viewers in their characters’ lives, capturing the momentous, often-tortuous rhythms of urban life. Monochrome and stasis images in Zhang Dalei’s The Summer is Gone, for example, convey a nostalgic, realist sensibility: the slow, unstretched existence of a rural Chinese community at the end of the 20th century. The film’s naturalistic images and minimal aesthetic echo characters’ lives and socio-cultural milieu. Wen Muye’s Dying to Survive also uses these methods, shooting at low contrast and handheld to convey the protagonist’s battles within an unsustainable healthcare system. And the raw imagery in the film mimics the suffering of everyday Chinese people, giving the narrative a raw feel, which makes audiences relate. Such a visual decision signifies a wider disenchantment with the romanticised, stylised spectacle of earlier Chinese cinema, and instead an honest, even grim vision of the life of a generation struggling with socio-economic hardship and rapid urbanisation. In avoiding the cinematic prettiness of earlier films, these filmmakers offer an intimate, flesh-to-machine experience that forces the viewer to face the brutality and uncertainty of modern existence [7]. That break with conventional aesthetics also enables cinematographers to present the human condition in a manner that is both intimate and universal, expressing the truth of contemporary Chinese life in an aesthetic language that is raw, subjective and grounded in the humdrum of everyday life. The visual language breaks the mold by creating a cinematic voice to represent the anxieties, struggles and perseverance of contemporary Chinese culture, which make these films not stories at all but rather experiences on a changing world.

3 Inheritance of Archetypal Film Structures in New Chinese Cinema

3.1 Preservation of Thematic Motifs

While future rogues indeed defy convention, they do so in ways that also carry and sustain themes that characterise Chinese film, suggesting a sense of cultural continuity even as they stretch imaginative boundaries. That tradition lays its teeth in tales of family, filial duty and the quasi-magical relationship between man and nature that continue to underpin Chinese storytelling. Filmmakers like Zhang Meng and Chen Sicheng, for instance, draw on family values such as loyalty, respect for elders and maintaining kinship, but they transform these into the needs of the modern world. For example, the tale of the father who cannot afford to raise his daughter, but willingly sacrifices himself to do so, in Zhang Meng’s The Piano in a Factory, exemplifies the lack of financial resources available to modern Chinese families, and emphasises sacrifice in the face of poverty. In a similar vein, Chen Sicheng’s Detective Chinatown series also focuses on the loyalty of families through a playful, adventurous lens, pleasing viewers with humor while still conveying a respect for family [8].

This persistence of such thematic themes in contemporary Chinese cinema is even more apparent in Table 1, which contrasts the themes at the core of traditional and contemporary Chinese cinema. As shown, family and the honour of tradition continue to be at the centre but are combined now with individualism, moral depth and social criticism in order to appeal to contemporary audiences.

Table 1. Thematic Evolution in Chinese Cinema (2000-2023)

Thematic Element

Classical Chinese Cinema

Contemporary Chinese Cinema (2000-2023)

Family and Filial Duty

Central, often idealized

Retained with nuanced conflicts against modern values

Personal Identity

Secondary to societal roles

Central, with emphasis on self-discovery and autonomy

Social Critique

Limited, implicit, indirect

Prominent, direct, focusing on justice and social change

Narrative Structure

Linear with morally clear conclusions

Non-linear, ambiguous, open-ended conclusions

Cinematic Style

Polished, stylized

Gritty, realistic, employing handheld shots and natural lighting

3.2 Cultural and Symbolic Elements as Markers of Inheritance

Symbols (traditional buildings, rural landscapes, cultural practices) are captured in the mise-en-scène of most Chinese movies today, both visual reminders of the inheritance and a physical connection to China’s history and culture. Filmmakers like Pema Tseden and Wang Xiaoshuai have frequently adopted such symbols not as props but as elements of the drama that add cultural meaning to the films. Rural Tibetan imagery and Buddhist icons suggest the spiritual and mystical struggle of the hero in Pema Tseden’s Tharlo, for example, an environment still steeped in tradition but under pressure from modernisation. Wang Xiaoshuai’s Beijing Bicycle similarly uses urban and rural locations to question the tension between past and present, with the metaphorical bicycle as a kind of portal between past and present. By sensibly inculcating these cultural symbols, new generation filmmakers craft a multi-layered visual language about the staying power of Chinese history that anchors their stories in a place and identity while the protagonists themselves must navigate the uncertainties of an ever-shifting world [9]. This formula allows filmmakers to balance reverence for the heritage with the necessity of telling stories that are in line with modern life, making movies that resonate with local and global audiences. These symbolic images, remained in the cinematic context, demonstrate the continuing relevance of cultural values, as the image of Chinese cinema remains historically embedded and reflects Chinese identity in a world increasingly global.

3.3 Inherited Storytelling Techniques Adapted for Modern Contexts

This legacy of storytelling devices (folklore, parables, allegory) still carries over into the work of current generation Chinese filmmakers, who translate them into modern problems while preserving cultural integrity. Filmmakers such as Zhao Liang and Yang Chao use conventional narrative structure to express layers of social critique, weaving the film’s narrative with nuances that point to moral and philosophical questions that are familiar to Chinese viewers. Zhao Liang’s Petition, for instance, is a documentary-style film that sheds light on the condition of people calling for justice, following the ancient practice of asking for redress from the elites and drawing attention to the bureaucratic challenges. In placing this contemporary social challenge in a context of oral history and petition tradition, Zhao links his book to cultural practices that have always depicted the fight for justice in Chinese society. Likewise, Yang Chao’s Crosscurrent (a river voyage to express love, loss and meaning) adopts allegorical devices from traditional Chinese poetry and philosophy. This poetic mode helps Yang compose a story informed by present social realities and anchored in ancient Chinese symbolism [10]. With the use of these traditional storytelling structures as an inspiration, these filmmakers make movies both for Chinese audiences familiar with the form and for an authentic cultural immersion for foreign viewers. This translation of inherited methods can be seen as a connecting thread between ancient forms of moral and social commentary and contemporary filmmaking that helps Chinese cinema continue to have a high level of cultural continuity. With this symmetry, emerging directors make it their business to make sure that Chinese storytelling archetypes continue to be both essential and applicable, a means to answer to contemporary concerns while simultaneously preserving the narrative tradition that has dominated Chinese cinema. This practice strengthens the position of these old narrative genres as tools of choice in the evolving idiom of modern Chinese cinema as a commentary on current social realities and a salute to the long history of Chinese storytelling.

4 Conclusion

A potent combination of defiance and patrimony has transformed the filmic culture of contemporary China through a new generation of Chinese directors who capture the layers of contemporary Chinese life. Using a freewheeling narrative, reimagining character tropes, and an open-ended unpolished cinematography, these filmmakers recast Chinese society as individualistic, existential, and socially politicised. This break with tradition has allowed them to speak about personal autonomy, identity and contemporary China, with characters who inhabit morally ambiguous realities and are subject to changing values due to urbanisation and globalisation. In all this innovation and outspokenness, these directors stay indelibly close to their cultural tradition, employing old-fashioned themes, imagery and narrative structures to make sure that they remain in conversation with the long tradition of Chinese cinema. In this convergence of ingenuity and cultural respect, they make generations-worthy films that present views that are culturally specific as well as universal.

Through this dualism, these directors are able to present Chinese cinema as both singularly local and universally accessible, and to bridge the distance between Chinese audiences and an international audience curious to grasp China’s shifting self. Continuing to cultivate their own cinematic vocabulary, these directors place Chinese cinema in a rich, powerful context for global cinema, a voice that brings philosophical understanding to issues of selfhood, purpose and humanity. This study speaks to the significance of these contributions, and how modern Chinese cinema rebranded itself as a mix of tradition and modernity. In this dynamic combination, Chinese cinema has forged a cinematic course that is simultaneously domestic and international, a unique global presence that documents the mutable terrain of China while speaking to common human needs.


References

[1]. Ma, Y. (2023). The evolution of Chinese cinema in the new century: From martial arts classics to new mainstream blockbusters. Journal of Research in Social Science and Humanities, 2(10), 37-42.

[2]. McGrath, J. (2023). Chinese film: Realism and convention from the silent era to the digital age. University of Minnesota Press.

[3]. Lupino, I. (2024). From auto-ethnography to autobiography: Representations of the past in contemporary Chinese cinema. Book Reviews.

[4]. McKelly, J. C. (n.d.). Youth cinema and the culture of rebellion.

[5]. Atef, N. (2024). Confused, rebellious and depressed: Liberated women in Egyptian cinema. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4841217

[6]. Guselnikova, I. (2023). Archetypes revisited: Investigating the power of universals in Soviet and Hollywood cinema (Master's thesis). University of South Carolina.

[7]. Hu, Z., Ismail, R., & Wang, C. (2024). Identity and cultural allegory amidst the Chinese new era: Analyzing narrative strategies of the Chinese science fiction film. Cogent Arts & Humanities, 11(1), 2313339.

[8]. Ceccarelli, G. (2023). The fragility of authorship for film directors in contemporary China. Serie orientale, 5(3).

[9]. Chen, X. (2024). A “creating god” experience of the Chinese film industry and aesthetics: Conversation with Wuershan, director of Creation of the Gods I: Kingdom of Storms. Journal of Chinese Film Studies.

[10]. Friedman, B. J. (2024). Remember me: The archetypal call for initiation in cinema (Master's thesis). Pacifica Graduate Institute.


Cite this article

Xue,F. (2024). Rebellion and Inheritance: A Study of Film Archetypes in Contemporary Chinese New Generation Directors’ Creations. Advances in Humanities Research,10,19-22.

Data availability

The datasets used and/or analyzed during the current study will be available from the authors upon reasonable request.

Disclaimer/Publisher's Note

The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of EWA Publishing and/or the editor(s). EWA Publishing and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.

About volume

Journal:Advances in Humanities Research

Volume number: Vol.10
ISSN:2753-7080(Print) / 2753-7099(Online)

© 2024 by the author(s). Licensee EWA Publishing, Oxford, UK. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license. Authors who publish this series agree to the following terms:
1. Authors retain copyright and grant the series right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgment of the work's authorship and initial publication in this series.
2. Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the series's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgment of its initial publication in this series.
3. Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See Open access policy for details).

References

[1]. Ma, Y. (2023). The evolution of Chinese cinema in the new century: From martial arts classics to new mainstream blockbusters. Journal of Research in Social Science and Humanities, 2(10), 37-42.

[2]. McGrath, J. (2023). Chinese film: Realism and convention from the silent era to the digital age. University of Minnesota Press.

[3]. Lupino, I. (2024). From auto-ethnography to autobiography: Representations of the past in contemporary Chinese cinema. Book Reviews.

[4]. McKelly, J. C. (n.d.). Youth cinema and the culture of rebellion.

[5]. Atef, N. (2024). Confused, rebellious and depressed: Liberated women in Egyptian cinema. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4841217

[6]. Guselnikova, I. (2023). Archetypes revisited: Investigating the power of universals in Soviet and Hollywood cinema (Master's thesis). University of South Carolina.

[7]. Hu, Z., Ismail, R., & Wang, C. (2024). Identity and cultural allegory amidst the Chinese new era: Analyzing narrative strategies of the Chinese science fiction film. Cogent Arts & Humanities, 11(1), 2313339.

[8]. Ceccarelli, G. (2023). The fragility of authorship for film directors in contemporary China. Serie orientale, 5(3).

[9]. Chen, X. (2024). A “creating god” experience of the Chinese film industry and aesthetics: Conversation with Wuershan, director of Creation of the Gods I: Kingdom of Storms. Journal of Chinese Film Studies.

[10]. Friedman, B. J. (2024). Remember me: The archetypal call for initiation in cinema (Master's thesis). Pacifica Graduate Institute.