1. Introduction
Chinese students generally had the experience of asking a teacher a question in class that they were initially eager to try, but in the end, because no one else raised their hands to answer, they still dared not stand up. Generally, success brings joy to people, but at specific times, while generating a sense of joy, success also comes with a psychological state of fear. Psychology calls it fear of success, which refers to the fear of winning in a competitive environment.
The fear of success can have many adverse effects on people, and some may engage in self-producing behaviors due to the fear of success, such as reducing life satisfaction, having difficulty in pursuing goals, lower self-esteem, and lower expectations.
We need to objectively analyze facts, approach and solve problems rationally, and engage in effective self-acceptance to promote the progress and development of individuals and even humanity.
In some cases, we may also develop a fear of success. For example, some people use their after-school time to communicate with teachers about social issues but are baseless and perceived by some classmates as reporting issues to the teacher. Therefore, these people are misunderstood, isolated, excluded, and even treated rudely by some classmates. So most people choose to remain silent, not be so eye-catching, learn to adapt to the outer environment, and no longer actively strive to improve. What exactly causes the exclusion of regular learning and communication behavior? What exactly causes people's fear of being outstanding?
This mentality is also known as the 'Jonah plot.' Jonah is an image in Christianity whose prototype is the "dove." The dove has a gentle and peaceful temperament. After completing an essential task of transmitting information, he gained a high reputation, but he was afraid, and he hid. This story reflects a mentality of avoiding and shrinking in the face of opportunities and challenges. It is like not being willing to face, being afraid to challenge, looking forward and backward.
Nevertheless, when the author saw others successfully challenge herself, she felt uncomfortable and unconvinced, thinking that others were lucky. The psychology of a person is so complex and strange. On the one hand, they yearn for success, but when faced with challenges and opportunities, they feel lost again. This is the fear of growth, not only of failure but also of success.
Therefore, the author has chosen to investigate and analyze the psychological phenomenon of fear of success, analyze the reasons for this psychological phenomenon, and find ways to respond to it actively.
2. The concept and negative impact of fear of success
2.1. The concept of fear of success
Fear of success is a concept proposed in the 1960s, which refers to the fear of winning in a competitive environment. General success can bring joy and joy to people, but at specific times, while generating joy and joy, success also comes with a psychological state of fear.
Some people believe that after achieving success, they need to face more challenging tasks and bear more significant pressure, and in this mode, they will be afraid of doing things well. They worried that they would fail next time, which may disappoint others' expectations, resulting in a fear of success.
Recent studies have shown that fear of success moderates the impact of goodwill gender bias on "male" occupational self-efficacy, with gender differences in this moderating effect. For males, fear of success plays a buffering role between goodwill gender bias and "male" occupational self-efficacy, while for females, it exacerbates it. Therefore, the relationship between benign gender bias and "male" occupational self-efficacy is regulated by fear of success, and this regulatory pattern varies depending on gender [1].
Other studies have shown that the tendency towards fear of success is more applicable to women. For many women, success has negative implications, such as being perceived as losing their femininity. In the fiercely competitive modern economic society, women should have played an important role in pursuing success like men. However, the role expectations and stereotypes of women in traditional culture make women exhibit different psychological characteristics when facing the problem of success. Men exhibit a calm and positive attitude toward success, while women are more likely to develop a fear of success. Karen Horney pointed out that men often hold the belief during their growth that if they want to achieve a particular wish, they must achieve success in life [2].
Psychologists have found that the so-called "boutique women" in the workplace are not as glamorous as they appear on the surface. They are starting to experience more and more psychological crises. For example, work dependency disorder, obsessive-compulsive disorder, and emotional isolation. Some people have a mentality that they do not deserve when faced with the beautiful things of success, and eventually, give up the good opportunities [3].
Horner's hypothesis is based on her analysis of gender culture and gender roles. She believes that women's expectations of adverse outcomes for success mainly have two aspects: one is fear of losing their female image, and the other is fear of being rejected by society. She pointed out that although our society is condemning the loss of women's potential and resources, it has not indeed recognized professional women [4].
2.2. The negative impact of fear of success
The fear of success can have a severe negative impact on people’s lives, which may hinder people from getting what they want in life, including:
Reducing Life Satisfaction: A study found that this fear can significantly reduce satisfaction with life;
The difficulty of pursuing goals: Research has also found that fear of achievement is related to the difficulty of initiating and maintaining behavior. Due to the difficulty of taking these first steps towards the goal, those concerned about success may find it challenging to get started. Otherwise, they may find themselves starting projects without the motivation to complete them;
Reduced self-esteem: Although achievement is usually associated with solid self-esteem, it may not be the case for those who are afraid of success. This is especially true for people who also suffer from impersonation syndrome, as they do not attribute their achievements to their skills, knowledge, or hard work;
Low expectations: Researchers also found that people concerned about success tend to adopt lower academic and career goals than their abilities.
Some people may be hindered due to fear of success. Self-obstruction refers to a behavior or thinking pattern in which people set obstacles for themselves, preventing them from achieving goals or success. This behavior pattern usually stems from an individual's internal anxiety and insecurity, as well as questioning their abilities and values.
Failure can threaten an individual's self-worth, inspiring them to fight against threats and protect themselves. One of the commonly used strategies is self-handicapping, also known as self-limiting, which means finding ways to attribute one's failure to external factors rather than oneself, such as poor environment, loud noise, physical discomfort, difficult exam questions, and so on.
Self-obstruction may also manifest as procrastination, excessive analysis, self-criticism, constant repetition of mistakes, and avoidance of challenging one's actions. In daily life, self-sabotage may also manifest as fear of trying new things, giving up opportunities to challenge oneself, being overly harsh on oneself, and so on. This behavior pattern will prevent people from fully realizing their potential, leading to their inability to achieve their goals and dreams. So why do we use this harmful way to hinder our success? The answer is to maintain our self-image, which is self-esteem.
The core element of self-esteem is emotional experience. Self-acceptance is one of the main components of self-esteem. Through correlation analysis, it was found that self-acceptance can significantly predict academic self-handicapping in high school students, indicating a negative correlation between self-acceptance and self-handicapping. The main reason for the above results is that self-evaluation reflects an individual's understanding of themselves. Students with higher self-evaluation may be individuals with stronger abilities, and they can clearly recognize and accept their strengths and weaknesses. The author will not use academic self-handicapping strategies with negative emotions due to failure. According to the definition of academic self-handicapping, the higher the tendency towards academic self-handicapping, the more individuals are unable to accept failure in unknown situations. Therefore, self-acceptance affects an individual's perception of failure, their level of acceptance of their abilities, and, thus, the self-protection mechanisms they adopt to avoid failure due to their abilities. College students with a high level of self-acceptance have a clear understanding and acceptance of their ability to complete tasks. Therefore, they can also moderately accept potential uncertain failures and do not excessively use self-hindering strategies [5].
3. Analysis of the Causes of Fear of Success
So, what is the fear of success? The fear of success includes the fear of achievement. Although it is generally believed that success is desirable, there may be a reason for fear of doing too well. It is essential to recognize that people often do not fear success itself. On the contrary, their fear focuses on the potential consequences of success. Because the expectation of success is usually based on the idea that achieving goals means sacrificing or enduring long-term losses, it is not surprising that people may be cautious about the cost that success may ultimately cost them [6].
There may be many different reasons for human fear of success.
3.1. Internal cause
Misunderstanding of success: Excitement and anxiety share many physiological signals. Therefore, sometimes, it is easy to misunderstand the feeling of excitement as tension or anxiety.
Negative Experience: People who have experienced some negative outcomes in the past after doing well (such as being ridiculed for being "showcased" or enduring hardships due to success, as listed in the background section of the author's life examples).
Poor self-efficacy: Self-efficacy refers to a person's beliefs and ability to achieve goals. Research has found that people afraid of success often have lower self-efficacy.
Shy or socially anxious individuals may fear success because they do not want to be the focus of attention.
Insufficient self-conditions: Due to insufficient self-conditions, one may develop a sense of inferiority and withdrawal, believing that "I can't" or "I can't," resulting in a withdrawal mentality. They also fear facing challenges and do not want to see the success of those who start the same journey. In short, this withdrawal and avoidance mentality hinders growth, and the "pigeon" mentality of fear of success will even hinder these people from achieving success.
3.2. External cause
3.2.1. The influence of national culture and conformity psychology
Under the traditional concept of the Doctrine of the Mean (manifested as a supreme morality, as well as a way of thinking and principles that emphasize "moderation," "persistence," and "application," and more politically manifested as a mixed political system of "co governance" logic), we have been educated from childhood to adulthood not to think we are superior to others, but to believe that there are people outside of us. Even if we achieve good results, we should not be complacent [7]. Both parents and teachers will tell us not to be proud but to continue working hard. Over time, we will feel that even if we make some achievements, it is not something to be happy about because there are still many people who are better than us. So, as we grow up in this environment, we will gradually lose interest in success, maintain a humble and ordinary attitude, and even deliberately cater to the public, trying to smooth out our edges and corners, ultimately leading to complacency and mediocrity. This is like the 'pigeon' that hides itself, hiding its edges and potential simultaneously and ultimately achieving nothing.
3.2.2. The impact of the surrounding environment
If the surrounding environment does not provide security and growth opportunities, people become "anxious about gains and losses," thus losing favorable opportunities.
In a larger environment, the probability of hidden traps under interests objectively educates a person's courage. If there are traps everywhere and seemingly visible benefits, there is a trap awaiting. People have to choose cautious and timid strategies to deal with complex and dangerous environments in this environment.
On the contrary, if the environment is very open, there is a high probability that people in this environment will choose aggressive strategies and achieve corresponding achievements.
4. Solutions to Fear of Success
To overcome the "Jonah complex" is a very complex psychological, cultural, and social issue. However, what we can do is to understand ourselves, believe in ourselves, face ourselves, and achieve the goal of "following our own path and letting others talk!" The author can provide the following suggestions for this:
Boldly acknowledge the existence of the "Jonah complex," but when facing responsibility and pressure, analyze oneself and believe in oneself. Have the courage and confidence to know that tigers are in the mountains and lean towards them.
Self-acceptance: Allow oneself to make mistakes, allow oneself to fail, but be sure to try. Nothing is complicated in the world; achievements are made by only those who have a heart. As long as we confirm, we can then take action. Even if we fail, we are still proud to be defeated.
Be brave enough to "volunteer" and take the initiative to face challenges: the more one retreats, the more fearful one becomes. However, when one takes a step forward and faces fear, they are less afraid. It is often necessary to take the initiative to try step by step in order to overcome fear gradually.
In short, if a person wants to achieve success, they must recognize and overcome their own "Jonah complex," admit that they also have a mentality of avoidance, analyze themselves more, believe in themselves, seize or try their best to create opportunities, take the initiative to try, and be brave in taking responsibility and pressure. Only in this way can they truly grow up and truly succeed [8].
Research suggests that the stronger an individual's ability to manage and regulate their emotions, the more reasonable and practical they will be in the face of stress. They tend to adopt more appropriate behaviors and measures to adapt. Therefore, they are less likely to develop self-sabotage. If an individual's emotional intelligence is low, they often adopt negative coping strategies to avoid failure when facing stressful situations, which is more likely to lead to self-sabotage.
5. Conclusion
Some people may engage in self-hindered behavior due to fear of success. We need to objectively analyze facts, approach and solve problems rationally, and engage in effective self-acceptance to promote individual and even human progress and development. However, this article only cites the research of other scholars for argumentation and analysis, and there is not yet sufficient experimental exploration scale to strongly prove this result. Therefore, future research can create a scale to scientifically and effectively prove the research results and make its contribution to human development [9].
References
[1]. Dai Zihan, Hu Junsheng. The impact of goodwill gender bias on "male" occupational self-efficacy: the moderating effect of gender and fear of success [J]. Psychological Research, 2021,14 (03): 236-243
[2]. Zhang Bailing. Analyzing Women's Avoidance of Success from a Cultural Perspective [J]. Exam Weekly, 2013 (56): 195
[3]. Three major psychological crises of "boutique women" [J]. Family Medicine. Happy Health Preservation, 2021 (06): 77
[4]. Qiang Haiyan. A Study on the Psychological Tendency of Women's "Fear of Success" [J]. Women's Research Series, 1999 (03): 4-9
[5]. Hong Ming, Fan Zhaoxiong. The relationship between self-esteem, self-handicapping, defensive pessimism, and fear of success among college students [J]. Chinese Journal of Mental Health, 2015,29 (03): 230-235
[6]. Li Hong, Xu Yong, He Xingxin et al. The relationship between academic self-handicapping and self-acceptance among high school students [J]. Chinese Journal of Health Psychology, 2016,24 (08): 1200-1203. DOI: 10.13342/j.cnki.cjhp.2016.08.023
[7]. Shi Yungui, Han Xinlian. On the "Governance" Thought of the Doctrine of the Mean and the Evolution of Political System: A Comparison Based on the Doctrine of the Mean between Confucius and Aristotle [J]. Journal of Guangxi University (Philosophy and Social Sciences Edition), 2023,45 (01): 115-123. DOI: 10.13624/j.cnki.jgupss.2023.01.009
[8]. Xu Fuming, Yu Peng, Li Meihua. A study on the learning adaptability of college students and its relationship with personality traits and social support [J]. China School Health, 2005, 26 (4): 299-300
[9]. Liu Xiaoting, Li Shangru, Lv Shixin, et al. Why Individuals with High Emotional Intelligence Use Self Obstructive Strategies Less [J]. Chinese Journal of Health Psychology, 2016,24 (11): 1728-1731. DOI: 10.13342/j.cnki. cjhp.2016.11.033
Cite this article
Kou,Y. (2024). Analysis of the Causes of Fear of Success Through Literature Review. Lecture Notes in Education Psychology and Public Media,36,56-61.
Data availability
The datasets used and/or analyzed during the current study will be available from the authors upon reasonable request.
Disclaimer/Publisher's Note
The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of EWA Publishing and/or the editor(s). EWA Publishing and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.
About volume
Volume title: Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Social Psychology and Humanity Studies
© 2024 by the author(s). Licensee EWA Publishing, Oxford, UK. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and
conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license. Authors who
publish this series agree to the following terms:
1. Authors retain copyright and grant the series right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons
Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgment of the work's authorship and initial publication in this
series.
2. Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the series's published
version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgment of its initial
publication in this series.
3. Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and
during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See
Open access policy for details).
References
[1]. Dai Zihan, Hu Junsheng. The impact of goodwill gender bias on "male" occupational self-efficacy: the moderating effect of gender and fear of success [J]. Psychological Research, 2021,14 (03): 236-243
[2]. Zhang Bailing. Analyzing Women's Avoidance of Success from a Cultural Perspective [J]. Exam Weekly, 2013 (56): 195
[3]. Three major psychological crises of "boutique women" [J]. Family Medicine. Happy Health Preservation, 2021 (06): 77
[4]. Qiang Haiyan. A Study on the Psychological Tendency of Women's "Fear of Success" [J]. Women's Research Series, 1999 (03): 4-9
[5]. Hong Ming, Fan Zhaoxiong. The relationship between self-esteem, self-handicapping, defensive pessimism, and fear of success among college students [J]. Chinese Journal of Mental Health, 2015,29 (03): 230-235
[6]. Li Hong, Xu Yong, He Xingxin et al. The relationship between academic self-handicapping and self-acceptance among high school students [J]. Chinese Journal of Health Psychology, 2016,24 (08): 1200-1203. DOI: 10.13342/j.cnki.cjhp.2016.08.023
[7]. Shi Yungui, Han Xinlian. On the "Governance" Thought of the Doctrine of the Mean and the Evolution of Political System: A Comparison Based on the Doctrine of the Mean between Confucius and Aristotle [J]. Journal of Guangxi University (Philosophy and Social Sciences Edition), 2023,45 (01): 115-123. DOI: 10.13624/j.cnki.jgupss.2023.01.009
[8]. Xu Fuming, Yu Peng, Li Meihua. A study on the learning adaptability of college students and its relationship with personality traits and social support [J]. China School Health, 2005, 26 (4): 299-300
[9]. Liu Xiaoting, Li Shangru, Lv Shixin, et al. Why Individuals with High Emotional Intelligence Use Self Obstructive Strategies Less [J]. Chinese Journal of Health Psychology, 2016,24 (11): 1728-1731. DOI: 10.13342/j.cnki. cjhp.2016.11.033