1.Introduction
With the changes of The Times and the continuous rise of the Internet economy, e-commerce, as a new form and model of business activities relying on the Internet and mobile Internet, has begun to appear frequently in the vision of consumers and realize capital flow The effective use of the combination of logistics and information flow shows a great picture for the development of China's economy. Simultaneously, the rapid ascent of e-commerce in China has precipitated an unprecedented challenge to traditional brick-and-mortar retail, as evidenced by the escalating inventory accumulation in certain retail sectors. To overcome this obstacle, conventional offline retailers must identify innovative strategies and forge synergistic partnerships with e-commerce platforms. By cultivating novel sales models that amalgamate the strengths of both online and offline retail, businesses can enhance their appeal to consumers and ensure continued relevance in an increasingly digital marketplace.
2.Literature review
2.1.Electronic Commerce
In China, the tentacles of e-commerce have penetrated every corner of people's lives, and its profound influence has made it an indispensable element of life in modern society. In this digital revolution, social e-commerce and live e-commerce are like two bright new stars, lighting up the market at an astonishing speed and leading the future trend of the retail industry Social e-commerce is a new business model that uses the power of social media to promote e-commerce transactions through socialization. As an innovative expansion in the field of e-commerce, its core lies in the use of diversified social media platforms as communication media[1]. Live streaming e-commerce refers to the business model of selling goods through online live streaming platforms, and reconstructs the three elements of human and freight fields using live streaming, but the essence is still e-commerce. As the product of the two-way integration of live streaming and e-commerce in the digital era, it has become an important part of the e-commerce industry[2].
2.2.The challenge of e-commerce to the traditional offline retail industry
In recent years, a lot of new players due to the emergence of e-commerce platforms, and in the market competition is intense, so the traditional offline retail industry suffered different dimensions of competition, not only from the previous similar industry competitors, but also consider the impact of cross-border emerging powers, lead to the profit space or living space is gradually tightening[3].At the same time when many retail enterprises enter the Internet era, they are faced with a major challenge: the lack of cutting-edge technology application and efficient management mode to effectively expand the sales territory, which intensifies the operating costs of enterprises, and some enterprises even fall into the predicament of loss [4].
2.3.Sales model adjustment and transformation
In response to such challenges and impacts, due to the serious problem of aging with fewer children in Japan, most managers in the traditional retail industry are elderly people, which has a profound impact on the operational efficiency of the industry, the speed of technology adoption and the orientation of strategic decision-making. With the aging of the age structure of employees, the ability to absorb and apply new technologies is also significantly weakened At the same time, as the main consumer group of new digital technology products, the reduction of the number of young people directly affects the market demand [5]. To a certain extent, the two have hindered the combination of Japan's traditional offline retail industry and e-commerce to adjust the form of sales model, so Japan only needs to seek breakthroughs in stability, and gradually accumulate significant competitive advantages through subtle and continuous improvement [6]. From this point of view, due to the implementation of China's full liberalization of the two-child policy to combat the problem of population aging [7]. China's traditional offline retail industry can not refer to Japan's adjustment countermeasures to look at the United States, multi-channel retail strategy has become an important strategy for offline retailers to increase trading volume to achieve economies of scale, while committed to improving operational efficiency to reduce operating costs These two strategies complement each other and help the offline retail industry in the United States achieve effective cost control and profitability improvement while maintaining competitiveness [8]. China's traditional offline retail industry can take this as a reference and effectively combine e-commerce to promote supply chain management innovation [9].
3.Methodology
3.1.Chart data analysis
Figure 1: National E-commerce Transaction Volume (2018-2022)(Source: National Bureau of Statistics of China) In the next five years, starting from 31.63 trillion yuan in 2018, the national e-commerce transaction volume continued to rise steadily to 43.83 trillion yuan.
As can be seen from Figure 1, in recent years, China's e-commerce transaction volume increased year by year, has become an irresistible trend, e-commerce industry shows a strong cross-industry penetration ability, both on the manufacturing wholesale industry, processing industry and other business sales have caused no small impact, while inevitably affecting the traditional retail industry as can be seen from Table 1, although the e-commerce transaction volume of the retail industry is no less than that of the computer communications and other electronic equipment manufacturing, wholesale industry and tobacco products industry, etc., the transaction volume after the integration of e-commerce is not to be underestimated, and has ranked among the top 10 industries Therefore, in the context of the development of e-commerce, traditional offline retail has to change its own sales model, if you want to gain a foothold in the future consumer market, you can not only focus on offline retail as in the past.
Table 1: Top 10 industries by e-commerce transaction volume (ranked by E-commerce transaction volume)(Source: National Bureau of Statistics of China)
rank |
Industry category |
Annual e-commerce turnover (100 million yuan) |
E-commerce sales(100 million yuan) |
E-commerce purchases (100 million yuan) |
Total |
28825.20 |
34656.14 |
22994.25 |
|
1 |
Computer, communications, and other electronic equipment manufacturing |
5081.71 |
5639.27 |
4524.15 |
2 |
Wholesale trade |
4918.56 |
6030.93 |
3806.19 |
3 |
Motor industry |
2929.85 |
3945.89 |
1913.81 |
4 |
Tobacco industries |
2860.98 |
4690.38 |
1031.58 |
5 |
Ferrous metal smelting and rolling industry |
1572.45 |
2229.20 |
915.70 |
6 |
Electrical machinery and equipment manufacturing |
1219.38 |
1181.01 |
1257.75 |
7 |
Electricity and heat production and supply industry |
1014.90 |
193.94 |
1835.87 |
8 |
Nonferrous metal smelting and rolling industry |
931.48 |
1080.72 |
782.24 |
9 |
Manufacturing of chemical raw materials and chemical products |
890.23 |
947.81 |
832.64 |
10 |
Retail industry |
757.21 |
863.08 |
651.33 |
Table 2: Ending commodity inventory of wholesale and Retail trade from 2018 to 2022 (RMB 100 million)(Source: National Bureau of Statistics of China)
The year 2018 |
The year 2019 |
The year 2020 |
The year 2021 |
The year 2022 |
|
Ending inventory of goods in wholesale and retail trade (RMB 100 million) |
42117.20 |
46410.00 |
52982.94 |
54539.40 |
57573.90 |
As can be seen from Table 2, in recent years, the ending commodity inventory of the wholesale and retail industry has increased year by year, which means that most wholesale and retailers have overstocked inventory. The operating pressure of traditional offline retail is increasing, and its operating costs are also increasing, which undoubtedly reduces profitability. Therefore, the transformation of traditional offline retail is imminent, and the pace of digital transformation needs to accelerate, open up online channels, and achieve online and offline integration to broaden sales channels and improve inventory entertainment turnover efficiency.
Table 3: Comparison of purchase channels by category (Data source: BIDmarket Research)
purchasing channel |
Adult clothing |
Children's Clothing |
Shoes and leather goods |
furniture |
beauty makeup |
Digital electric appliance |
entertainment |
educational training |
|
online |
Integrated e-commerce platform |
77% |
69% |
73% |
73% |
74% |
75% |
56% |
49% |
New online channel |
36% |
35% |
37% |
35% |
38% |
31% |
51% |
53% |
|
Department stores/shopping centers |
46% |
48% |
44% |
44% |
37% |
33% |
34% |
22% |
|
brand monopolized shop |
42% |
42% |
36% |
34% |
41% |
39% |
18% |
32% |
|
offline |
supermarket |
23% |
23% |
27% |
35% |
25% |
27% |
27% |
28% |
Ole/Discount Store |
13% |
12% |
13% |
8% |
7% |
5% |
1% |
0.4% |
|
convenience store |
4% |
4% |
3% |
24% |
20% |
8% |
13% |
10% |
It can be seen from the comparison of the purchase percentage of various types of demand of online channels and offline channels in Table 3 that offline purchase has been a general trend in the background of e-commerce, no matter it is clothing Shoes, bags, and leather goods or recreational goods, most consumers are more willing to choose online channels to buy, especially the integrated e-commerce platform, it can be seen that a single offline retail has long been unable to meet the consumer needs of contemporary consumers.
3.2.SWOT analysis of the traditional offline retail industry
3.2.1.Strengths analysis
For the traditional offline retail industry, the instant shopping experience is a factor that makes it irreplaceable in a variety of scenarios. Consumers can take away and use the goods immediately after purchasing them, without waiting for delivery like online shopping[10]. At the same time, the offline shopping environment gives consumers a unique opportunity for a physical experience so that they can touch and try the product with their own hands. This intuitive contact greatly enhances consumers' trust and confidence in the product. Compared with online shopping, consumers do not need to judge by picture description or virtual model, but can directly observe the material details of the product. Evaluate the quality level, and confirm whether the size of the product perfectly fits the individual needs [11]. Through such face-to-face communication, the barriers of information asymmetry are effectively reduced, and consumers can make more informed and satisfied purchase decisions while reducing the return and dissatisfaction caused by products that do not meet expectations.
3.2.2.Weaknesses analysis
In the current digital wave, consumers' information acquisition paths and shopping modes are undergoing unprecedented changes. The seamless interaction of social media and the convenience of shopping on e-commerce platforms have made more and more consumers shift their focus from offline to online consumption. This transformation makes information dissemination and commodity transactions increasingly rely on the digital space However, in the face of the profound changes in this consumption phenomenon, some traditional offline retail enterprises appear to be slow in the market strategy deployment, and fail to fully grasp the pulse of The Times. They still cling to the old thinking mode, relying too much on past successful experience, and ignoring the market opportunities and challenges brought by new technologies and new platforms In terms of target market segmentation and positioning, these enterprises fail to make effective use of big data, a powerful tool, to dig deeply into the changes of consumers' behavior patterns, preferences, and potential demands, which leads to the ambiguity of market positioning and the failure of marketing strategies [12]. At the same time, the lack of product innovation leads to the lack of differentiation in the consumer market, which is also extremely obvious. More and more consumers tend to personalize their consumption trend, and they usually look for freshness and satisfaction in consumption, while homogenization seriously leads to saturation of the market, and consumers are faced with a lot of functional quality design or appearance On this basis, the industry may potentially reduce the loyalty of consumers to the specific brand they have been buying. As for the added value of the brand, homogenized goods cannot be effectively improved, and eventually, the competitiveness of the brand in the consumer market will greatly decline.
3.2.3.Opportunity analysis
In the current complex and changing market environment, the traditional offline retail industry is ushering in a strong wave of transformation, of which digital transformation is its key opportunity through the introduction of advanced technologies such as big data cloud computing artificial intelligence, traditional offline retail enterprises can achieve precision marketing personalized recommendation inventory management optimization and other functions For the problems mentioned in the above disadvantages, through big data analysis of consumer purchasing behavior and preferences, enterprises can develop more targeted marketing strategies and improve sales conversion rates. At the same time, for the problem of ending inventory overstocking as shown in Table 3, the intelligent inventory management system can be used to monitor the inventory situation in real time, avoid excessive overstocking or stock shortage, and reduce operating costs.
3.2.4.Threat analysis
With the popularity of e-commerce and its e-commerce platform, consumers' shopping habits have changed significantly. More and more customers turn to e-commerce platforms. The driving force behind this phenomenon lies in the unparalleled convenience shown by the e-commerce platform, the unprecedented variety of goods, and the significant advantage in price. At the same time, after the development of Internet of Things technology, self-service shopping without retail has appeared in the consumer market, consumers buy their bills, greatly saving time and cost, this convenient shopping method has attracted many consumers who pursue high efficiency, and its 24-hour uninterrupted service model has brought great convenience to consumers who work at night[13].The transformation of this shopping mode, like an unstoppable trend, directly impacts the operation ecology of traditional offline retail stores, resulting in thinning store customer flow and declining sales, forcing the entire retail industry to re-examine and adjust its sales and business model
4.Discussion
Behind the above multi-table analysis and SWOT analysis, a message is revealed that the sales model of offline retail must be changed, digital transformation must be carried out, and comprehensive online and offline sales integration can be achieved. Otherwise, even if there is a unique advantage of the instant shopping experience, it will inevitably be difficult to survive in the consumer market fully penetrated by e-commerce in the future.
Enterprises are gradually moving towards the sustainable development path of deep integration of physical retail and online retail, which indicates the long-term trend of the future market. The key to the sustainable development of traditional offline retail is to build and continue to innovate the business model of online and offline collaborative development, but in the offline + offline collaborative sales model, seamless integration of technological innovation Process optimization, and multi-party collaborative management have become a problem for many merchants. In this process, the balance of the relationship between all parties and the coordination of positions has become a major challenge. Due to the natural differences and competition between different departments and different stakeholders, how to maximize the sharing and utilization of resources while maintaining their respective advantages has become the key to collaborative management. Based on the analysis, the government encourages online and offline interactive innovation technology application innovation, including tolerance and encouragement of business model innovation, and releases the vitality of the trade circulation market[14]. Promote the digital transformation of physical stores, through the deep integration of Internet technology, not only the online platform's wonderful display and sales of goods and services, but also vigorously improve the experience of offline stores distribution efficiency and after-sales service quality, and build seamless online and offline shopping ecology[15]. At the same time, the government can set up special funds to give one-time or phased financial subsidies to enterprises that meet the transformation and upgrading standards. The amount of subsidies can be differentiated according to factors such as the scale of the transformation of enterprises, the amount of investment, and innovation achievements. At the same time, the government will encourage enterprises to increase the upgrading of technological innovation equipment The investment in personnel training and other aspects, and the corresponding proportion of subsidies for these actual investments, can not only effectively alleviate the financial pressure of enterprises, but also encourage them to more actively promote the transformation and upgrading process.
The industry should guide its future development based on the detailed classification and specification of retail formats based on the national standard retail format Classification[16].while encouraging enterprises to actively participate in the formulation of international standards, national standards, and industry standards, and lead the industrial development with advanced standards. Offline retailers should actively respond to government policies, innovate sales models, and develop smart retail[17].For example, new retail formats such as smart supermarkets and smart stores use big data analysis and artificial intelligence technology to improve customer experience and operational efficiencies[18].For reference, BBK and Tencent cooperate to build a data-driven smart retail enterprise[19].
At the same time, in combination with social e-commerce, cooperating with key opinion leaders (KOL) such as Internet celebrities or industry experts to directly display the product use process and effect on social e-commerce platforms through short live videos of TikTok Xiaored Book, etc., providing consumers with the immersive shopping experience and using big data analysis to help enterprises identify different fields Different styles of KOL fan groups of interest points and consumption preferences, and then customized push personalized products and services KOL with its unique insight style and presentation for these precise audiences to provide valuable shopping advice[20].
5.Conclusion
This paper aims to study how traditional offline retail can quickly adapt to the overall development trend of e-commerce while gaining a firm foothold in the consumer market Through data analysis of wholesale, retail ending commodity inventory, comparison of online and offline purchase channels, and SWOT analysis of traditional offline retail, it can be concluded that the digital transformation of e-commerce is the only way for conventional offline retail. At the same time, it deeply analyzes the severe impact and challenge of traditional offline retail under the background of the rapid development of e-commerce In response to these challenges, we have carefully constructed a series of innovative strategies, that enrich the transformation path of traditional retail industry, provide traditional retail enterprises with operational transformation solutions, and help them to stand firm in the fierce market competition and achieve sustainable development.
References
[1]. Zhu Y H., Wang B R., & Zi Z Y., (2019). Research on the status quo, development trends, and problems of social e-commerce. Modern marketing (management), (3), 127.doi:10.19921/j.cnki.1009-2994.2019.03.095.
[2]. Li R Z., (2024). Analysis of the development path and optimization model of live streaming cargo under the background of rural revitalization. China Merchants (12), 36 to 39. doi:10.19699/j.cnki.issn2096-0298.2024.12.036.
[3]. Lin Z Q., (2024). Innovative Thinking on the innovation model of Chinese circulation enterprises under the background of e-commerce. Environment and Development (4),
[4]. Xu M. (2022). Research on retail enterprise Management model Innovation in the context of e-commerce environment. Circulation of the national economy (35), 24-27, doi:10.16834/j.cnki.issn1009-5292.2022.35.033.
[5]. Luo X Y., (2024). Research on the interaction mechanism and coupling coordination between the digital economy and digital technology innovation development in Japan from the perspective of knowledge innovation. Science and Technology Management Research (09), 45-54
[6]. Liao W F., & Huang Y N., (2022). Research on the innovation path of experiential service formats under the Background of New retail -- A case study of Japanese service retail formats. Shanghai Commerce (04), 37-39.
[7]. Yang Z K., & Song Y., (2006). Research on the Inner Driving Force of retail Format Change: American experience and Chinese practice. Shanghai Management Science (03), 49-53.
[8]. Wu F. (2016). Family policy support: the path of balanced population development after the universal two-child liberalization. Guangdong Social Sciences (04), 196-202.
[9]. Hu W L., Yan L B., & Guan J F., (2024). Research on the integration mechanism of digital economy and real economy from the perspective of e-commerce development. Research in Business Economics (03), 123-127.
[10]. Ge Y N., (2023).A Master's Degree in Marketing Optimization Strategy of Traditional Retail Enterprises (Dissertation, East China Normal University). Master https://link.cnki.net/doi/10.27149/d.cnki.ghdsu.2023.004327doi:10.27149/d.cnki.ghdsu.2023.004327.
[11]. Li J Y. (2016). Business model construction under the collaborative evolution of physical and online retail. Research in Business Economics (23), 27-29.
[12]. Dong S S., (2024). On Marketing of retail industry in network era. Time-honored Brand Marketing (08), 12-14.
[13]. Zhang Y. (2024). Strategy analysis on enhancing the brand image of Chinese apparel in the era of product homogeneity. Liaoning Silk (02), 68-69+42.
[14]. General Office of the State Council. (2015). General Office of the State Council on promoting online and offline interaction Opinions on accelerating innovation, development, transformation and upgrading of commercial circulation(Guochangfa [2015] 72 ). Retrieved from https://www.gov.cn/zhengce/content/202211/content_6604256.htm
[15]. General Office of the State Council. (2023). The General Office of the State Council forwarded a notice from the National Development and Reform Commission on measures to restore and (expand consumption(State Office Letter (2023) No. 70). Retrieved from https://www.gov.cn/zhengce/content/202307/content_6895599.htm
[16]. China Chain Store & Franchise Association. (2021). The revised version of the national standard "Classification of Retail Formats" was officially implemented. Retrieved from http://www.ccfa.org.cn/portal/cn/xiangxi.jsp?id=443461&type=34
[17]. Luo, Y. 2022. The CPC Central Committee and The State Council: Accelerate the digital transformation, transformation, and upgrading of traditional offline business formats. Available from https://www.yicai.com/news/101624356.html
[18]. Han X Z., & Li M L., (2023). Operation logic and Advantages and disadvantages of unmanned supermarket under the new retail model. Expo economy (14), 22-25. doi:10.19995/j.cnki.CN10-1617/F7.2023.14.022.
[19]. Peking University Management Case Study Center. (2022). BBK x Tencent, the digital transformation of traditional retail industry | Guanghua case. Available from https://www.thepaper.cn/newsDetail_forward_10522646.
[20]. Wang Q. (2024). Social Marketing in the era of Big Data. Digital Communication World (04), 185-187.
Cite this article
Zou,W. (2024). E-commerce and the Transformation of Offline Retail in China: Based on the Perspective of Sales Model Transformation. Advances in Economics, Management and Political Sciences,125,35-42.
Data availability
The datasets used and/or analyzed during the current study will be available from the authors upon reasonable request.
Disclaimer/Publisher's Note
The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of EWA Publishing and/or the editor(s). EWA Publishing and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.
About volume
Volume title: Proceedings of the 8th International Conference on Economic Management and Green Development
© 2024 by the author(s). Licensee EWA Publishing, Oxford, UK. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and
conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license. Authors who
publish this series agree to the following terms:
1. Authors retain copyright and grant the series right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons
Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgment of the work's authorship and initial publication in this
series.
2. Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the series's published
version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgment of its initial
publication in this series.
3. Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and
during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See
Open access policy for details).
References
[1]. Zhu Y H., Wang B R., & Zi Z Y., (2019). Research on the status quo, development trends, and problems of social e-commerce. Modern marketing (management), (3), 127.doi:10.19921/j.cnki.1009-2994.2019.03.095.
[2]. Li R Z., (2024). Analysis of the development path and optimization model of live streaming cargo under the background of rural revitalization. China Merchants (12), 36 to 39. doi:10.19699/j.cnki.issn2096-0298.2024.12.036.
[3]. Lin Z Q., (2024). Innovative Thinking on the innovation model of Chinese circulation enterprises under the background of e-commerce. Environment and Development (4),
[4]. Xu M. (2022). Research on retail enterprise Management model Innovation in the context of e-commerce environment. Circulation of the national economy (35), 24-27, doi:10.16834/j.cnki.issn1009-5292.2022.35.033.
[5]. Luo X Y., (2024). Research on the interaction mechanism and coupling coordination between the digital economy and digital technology innovation development in Japan from the perspective of knowledge innovation. Science and Technology Management Research (09), 45-54
[6]. Liao W F., & Huang Y N., (2022). Research on the innovation path of experiential service formats under the Background of New retail -- A case study of Japanese service retail formats. Shanghai Commerce (04), 37-39.
[7]. Yang Z K., & Song Y., (2006). Research on the Inner Driving Force of retail Format Change: American experience and Chinese practice. Shanghai Management Science (03), 49-53.
[8]. Wu F. (2016). Family policy support: the path of balanced population development after the universal two-child liberalization. Guangdong Social Sciences (04), 196-202.
[9]. Hu W L., Yan L B., & Guan J F., (2024). Research on the integration mechanism of digital economy and real economy from the perspective of e-commerce development. Research in Business Economics (03), 123-127.
[10]. Ge Y N., (2023).A Master's Degree in Marketing Optimization Strategy of Traditional Retail Enterprises (Dissertation, East China Normal University). Master https://link.cnki.net/doi/10.27149/d.cnki.ghdsu.2023.004327doi:10.27149/d.cnki.ghdsu.2023.004327.
[11]. Li J Y. (2016). Business model construction under the collaborative evolution of physical and online retail. Research in Business Economics (23), 27-29.
[12]. Dong S S., (2024). On Marketing of retail industry in network era. Time-honored Brand Marketing (08), 12-14.
[13]. Zhang Y. (2024). Strategy analysis on enhancing the brand image of Chinese apparel in the era of product homogeneity. Liaoning Silk (02), 68-69+42.
[14]. General Office of the State Council. (2015). General Office of the State Council on promoting online and offline interaction Opinions on accelerating innovation, development, transformation and upgrading of commercial circulation(Guochangfa [2015] 72 ). Retrieved from https://www.gov.cn/zhengce/content/202211/content_6604256.htm
[15]. General Office of the State Council. (2023). The General Office of the State Council forwarded a notice from the National Development and Reform Commission on measures to restore and (expand consumption(State Office Letter (2023) No. 70). Retrieved from https://www.gov.cn/zhengce/content/202307/content_6895599.htm
[16]. China Chain Store & Franchise Association. (2021). The revised version of the national standard "Classification of Retail Formats" was officially implemented. Retrieved from http://www.ccfa.org.cn/portal/cn/xiangxi.jsp?id=443461&type=34
[17]. Luo, Y. 2022. The CPC Central Committee and The State Council: Accelerate the digital transformation, transformation, and upgrading of traditional offline business formats. Available from https://www.yicai.com/news/101624356.html
[18]. Han X Z., & Li M L., (2023). Operation logic and Advantages and disadvantages of unmanned supermarket under the new retail model. Expo economy (14), 22-25. doi:10.19995/j.cnki.CN10-1617/F7.2023.14.022.
[19]. Peking University Management Case Study Center. (2022). BBK x Tencent, the digital transformation of traditional retail industry | Guanghua case. Available from https://www.thepaper.cn/newsDetail_forward_10522646.
[20]. Wang Q. (2024). Social Marketing in the era of Big Data. Digital Communication World (04), 185-187.