Comparative Analysis of the Monetary Policy Practices: A Case Study of China and the United States

Research Article
Open access

Comparative Analysis of the Monetary Policy Practices: A Case Study of China and the United States

Yonghao Liu 1*
  • 1 University of Aberdeen    
  • *corresponding author u12yl22@abdn.ac.uk
Published on 10 November 2023 | https://doi.org/10.54254/2754-1169/40/20231984
AEMPS Vol.40
ISSN (Print): 2754-1169
ISSN (Online): 2754-1177
ISBN (Print): 978-1-83558-101-8
ISBN (Online): 978-1-83558-102-5

Abstract

Currency policy plays a crucial role in macroeconomic management and is of significant importance for the economic stability and development of countries and regions. Understanding and evaluating the choices and consequences of different countries' currency policy practices are essential. This paper aims to compare and analyze the currency policy practices of China and the United States, two important economic entities, and explore their core elements, policy objectives, and impact on economic stability and growth. China, as the world's second-largest economy, has implemented a series of unique monetary policy measures to address domestic and external challenges. The United States, as the largest economy in the world, has a long-standing tradition of stable monetary policy and faces challenges and responsibilities consistent with its economic status.

Keywords:

currency policy, China, United States, comparative analysis, core elements, policy objectives, economic stability, inflation control, employment, economic growth

Liu,Y. (2023). Comparative Analysis of the Monetary Policy Practices: A Case Study of China and the United States. Advances in Economics, Management and Political Sciences,40,28-33.
Export citation

1. Introduction

As an important tool for macroeconomic management, monetary policy is important for national and regional economic stability and development. Different countries and regions have their own characteristics and preferences in the formulation and practice of monetary policy, depending on their economic conditions, institutional arrangements, and development goals. Therefore, comparing monetary policy practices across countries and regions is critical to an in-depth understanding and assessment of the advantages and disadvantages of national policy choices.

This paper aims to explore the core elements, policy objectives, and impacts on economic stability and growth by comparing the monetary policy practices of two major economies: China and the United States. As the world’s second-largest economy, China has implemented a series of extraordinary monetary policy measures to address domestic and external challenges. As the world’s largest economy, the United States has a long-standing tradition of stable monetary policy and faces challenges and responsibilities in line with its economic status.

First, this article will compare the core elements of China’s and the U.S. monetary policy frameworks, including interest rate policies, monetary supply, and liquidity management. By analyzing the institutional arrangements and implementation of monetary policy between the two countries, we will reveal their commonalities and differences in monetary-policy practices.

Second, we will explore in depth the goals and effects of China’s and the U.S.'s monetary policies. In particular, the role and impact of monetary policy may differ in terms of inflation control, employment, and economic growth. We will evaluate the strategies and effectiveness of the two countries in responding to challenges such as the financial crisis and recession, and explore the coordination of monetary policy with other economic policies.

Finally, by comparing the findings of China’s and the U.S.'s monetary policy practices, we will summarize the similarities and differences between them and provide useful insights into monetary policy practices. These findings will help policymakers better understand the characteristics and effects of monetary policies in different countries and regions, and what factors should be considered when formulating appropriate monetary policy frameworks and measures.

In summary, this paper aims to explore its core elements, policy objectives, and impacts on the economy through a comparative analysis of China’s and the U.S.'s monetary policy practices.

2. The Monetary Policy Framework of China and the United States

The Monetary Policy Framework refers to the core elements and mechanisms adopted by a country or region in formulating and implementing monetary policy. The monetary policy framework of different countries and regions may vary depending on their economic systems, development goals, and policy preferences. This section will focus on comparing the monetary policy frameworks of the two major economies of China and the United States, analyzing their differences in core factors.

2.1. The Interest Rate Policy

Interest rate policy is one of the most important instruments of monetary policy and has a direct impact on economic activity and financial markets. There are some differences between China and the United States in interest rates. China’s monetary policy aims to maintain reasonable liquidity and stable interest rates and regulates the money supply and credit conditions by changing the deposit reserve rate and interest rate levels. U.S. monetary policy is led by the Federal Reserve, which influences market interest rates and borrowing costs by adjusting the federal fund interest rate [1].

2.2. Money Supply and Liquidity

2.2.1. Management

Money supply and liquidity management are key components of the monetary policy framework. China has taken a variety of measures to manage money supply and liquidity, including regulating the liquidity of the currency market by means of open market operations, deposit reserves, and reverse repurchases. In contrast, the U.S. uses open market operations to regulate the money supply and influence the money supply on the market by buying and selling instruments such as government bonds.

2.3. Objectives of Monetary

2.3.1. Policy

Monetary policy objectives may vary between countries and regions. China’s monetary policy objectives include price stability and promoting economic growth and employment. China’s policymakers typically adopt a robust monetary policy to avoid inflation and financial risks [2]. In contrast, U.S. monetary policy targets are more diversified and focus on balancing employment and economic growth in addition to controlling inflation to stabilize the overall economy.

2.4. Monetary Policy

2.4.1. Independence and Transparency

Monetary policy independence and transparency are critical to building market confidence and monetary policy effectiveness. There are some differences between China and the United States in this regard. China’s monetary policy is relatively concentrated, the country has greater decision-making power, and the role of policymakers is mainly held by the People’s Bank of China to ensure the coherence and stability of monetary policies. Meanwhile, China’s monetary policy decision-making process is somewhat lacking in transparency, and market participants have a limited understanding of policy-making and dynamics [3].

In contrast, the U.S. monetary the policy decision-making process is more decentralized and transparent. The Federal Reserve adopts the institutional arrangements of the Federal Open, Market Commission (FOMC), which consists of the governors of the federal reserve bank and members of the board of directors of the regions to determine the direction of interest rates and monetary policy. In addition, the Fed regularly releases monetary policy statements and meeting reports to deliver decision-making information to markets to increase transparency and guide market expectations.

By comparing the core elements of China’s and U.S. monetary policy frameworks, we can see differences in interest rate policies, monetary supply and liquidity management, policy objectives, and policy independence and transparency. These differences reflect differences between countries in economic systems and development goals, as well as different preferences and focus on monetary policy.

3. The Role and Impact of China and US Monetary Policy

In the next section, we will explore the role and impact of China’s and U.S. monetary policy in order to further deepen our understanding of comparative analysis.

Monetary policy is an important tool for a country or region to regulate the supply of money and the level of interest rates and has a broad impact on economic activity and financial markets. This section will focus on the role and impact of China and the U.S. monetary policy on economic stability, inflation control, employment and economic growth.

3.1. Economic Stability

Monetary policy plays an important role inlining economic stability. By adjusting interest rates, money supply and liquidity, monetary policy can adjust the economic cycle to prevent excessive inflation or deflation and maintain price stability. In China, price stability is one of the primary goals of monetary policy, and the Chinese government strives to avoid the risk of inflation and deflation through reasonable monetary supply and interest rate control. In the United States, the Fed monetary policy is also dedicated toning stable inflation levels to ensure steady economic growth.

3.2. Control of Inflation

Monetary policy is crucial for controlling inflation. Too high or too low inflation can have a negative impact on the economy. Monetary policy influences overall demand by regulating money supply and interest rates. In China, one of the goals of monetary policy is to control inflation in order to maintain price stability. By adjusting interest rates and liquidity management, the Chinese government seeks to maintain a reasonable level of inflation. U.S. monetary policy is also focused on controlling inflation, and the Fed achieves its inflation targets by adjusting interest rates and adopting other monetary instruments [4].

3.3. Employment

The impact of monetary policy on employment is also important. Moderate monetary policy can boost economic growth and increase employment opportunities. In China, one of the goals of monetary the policy is to promote economic growth and employment. By adjusting the supply of money and interest rates, the Chinese government is trying to create a macro-environment that is conducive to job growth. U.S. monetary policy also takes into account employment factors, and the Federal Reserve seeks to balance employment and economic growth to support labor market stability and increased employment opportunities.

3.4. Economic Growth

Monetary policy has a significant impact on economic growth. By adjusting the level of money supply and interest rates, monetary policy can stimulate investment and consumer demand and boost economic growth. In China, one of the goals of monetary policy is to support economic growth. By providing a moderate supply of money and a stable interest rate environment, the Chinese government encourages investment and consumption and promotes economic growth. U.S. monetary policy is also dedicated to supporting economic growth, with the Federal Reserve stimulating economic activity and increasing investment through interest rate regulation and the use of monetary-policy tools.

4. Discussion

By comparing the monetary policy of China and the United States, we can come to the following findings:

First is, the difference in objectives. China’s monetary policy objectives are mainly focused on stabilizing prices, inning financial stability, and promoting economic growth. The Chinese government is stimulating economic growth by controlling inflation, in the stability of monetary supply and moderate monetary easing policies. In contrast, U.S. monetary policy targets are more comprehensive, aiming at achieving price stability, maximizing employment an diningd economic growth.

Second is, the differences in policy instruments. China’s monetary policy mainly influences the monetary supply and market rates by means of interest rate regulation, reserve rate adjustment, and credit policy. The Chinese government also promotes economic growth and supports the development of key industries by guiding bank credit and lending. The U.S. monetary policy is more focused on interest rate regulation, and the Federal The reserve influences market rates and money supply by controlling federal fund interest rates and buying and selling government bonds.

Third is, the differences between decision-making bodies. In China, the decision-making power of monetary policy is concentrated in the People's Bank of China, and the government has a greater influence on monetary policies. In the U.S., monetary policy decision-making is decentralized among members of the Federal Open Market Commission (FOMC), and decision-making is more transparent, allowing market participants to better anticipate and understand the policy’s direction.

In addition, comparative analysis can also reveal differences in China’s and U.S. monetary policies in response to financial crises and external shocks. During the global financial crisis, China has taken positive monetary and fiscal stimulus measures to promote the economic recovery. The U.S. has taken more flexible and diversified policy measures, including lowering interest rates and buying government bonds, to stabilize financial markets and boost economic growth.

Overall, by comparing China’s and U.S. monetary policy practices, we can find that there are some difference between them in terms of setting targets, policy tools, and decision-making bodies. These differences reflect the different stages of economic development, policy needs, and institutional environments in different countries. Understanding these differences can help us better understand the implementation and effects of monetary policy and provide reference and reference to other countries and regions.

Despite the differences, we can also, find some commonalities. First, whether in China or the United States, monetary policy is designed to maintain economic stability and promote sustainable growth. Both countries recognize that monetary policy needs to be coordinated with other economic policies in order to overall economic goals [5]. Finally, both countries recognized the importance of flexibility and adaptability in monetary policy, especially in the face of uncertainty and external shocks.

5. Summary and Prospects

In summarizing the main findings and views of this paper, we must acknowledge that there are some limitations in this study. First, we selected only China and the United States as comparison objects, and monetary policy practices in other countries and regions are also important. Second, this paper is only a preliminary discussion of the role and impact of monetary policy, and there are more factors and variables that need further study and analysis.

For policymakers, the results of this study has important policy insights. They can learn from experiences and lessons from monetary policy practices in different countries and regions, providing references and drawbacks for their own monetary policies. In addition, this study also provides guidance for future research, allowing further exploration of monetary policy practices in other countries and regions, and an in-depth study of their effects and effects.

Finally, we emphasize the importance of monetary policy, which has a significant impact on economic stability and growth. Effective monetary policy can help stabilize price levels, boost economic growth, and maintain employment and financial stability. However, monetary policy is not the only factor that solves all economic problems, it also requires coordination and coordination with other economic policies.

In future research, the following aspects can be further explored:

1. The timing effectiveness of monetary policy: Sstudying the timing effect of monetary policy, i.e. how long it takes to show the effects of policy measures on the economy, and exploreing the transmission mechanisms and timing of the effects.

2. Non-linear effects of monetary policy: The study of the non-linear effects of monetary policy at different economic stages or in different market conditions can be studied in order to better understand the flexibility and adaptability of Monetary Policy [6].

3. Regional Differences and Monetary Policy: Ccomparing the monetary policy practices of different regions or countries to explore the effects of the economic structure and characteristics of financial markets in different regions and countries on monetary policies.

4. Monetary Policy Response Strategies: Sstudying monetary policy strategies in response to financial crises, external shocks and uncertainty, and exploreing the flexibility and adaptability of monetary policies in different contexts.

Monetary policy plays an important role and influence in countries and regions such as China and the United States. By comparing monetary policy practices in different countries and regions, we can understand their differences in frameworks, goals, tools and decision-making processes. At the same time, the effects of monetary policy on economic stability, inflation control, employment, and economic growth are also worth studying in depth. This provides policy insight to policymakers and guides future research to better understand the role and effects of monetary policy and provide better guidance for economic development.


References

[1]. "Introduction to U.S. Economy: Monetary Policy ", crsreports.congress.gov, (Accessed 4 Jun. 2023).

[2]. "Monetary Policy in China - Cornell University", prasad.dyson.cornell.edu, (Accessed 4 Jun. 2023).

[3]. "China’s Monetary Policy: Institutional Setting, Tools and Challenges", link.springer.com, (Accessed 4 Jun. 2023).

[4]. "Federal Reserve Board - Monetary Policy", federalreserve.gov, (Accessed 5 Jun. 2023).

[5]. "Is China better at monetary policy than America? - The Economist", economist.com, (Accessed 4 Jun. 2023).

[6]. "The non-linear impact of monetary policy on international reserves ...", link.springer.com, (Accessed 4 Jun. 2023).


Cite this article

Liu,Y. (2023). Comparative Analysis of the Monetary Policy Practices: A Case Study of China and the United States. Advances in Economics, Management and Political Sciences,40,28-33.

Data availability

The datasets used and/or analyzed during the current study will be available from the authors upon reasonable request.

Disclaimer/Publisher's Note

The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of EWA Publishing and/or the editor(s). EWA Publishing and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.

About volume

Volume title: Proceedings of the 7th International Conference on Economic Management and Green Development

ISBN:978-1-83558-101-8(Print) / 978-1-83558-102-5(Online)
Editor:Canh Thien Dang
Conference website: https://www.icemgd.org/
Conference date: 6 August 2023
Series: Advances in Economics, Management and Political Sciences
Volume number: Vol.40
ISSN:2754-1169(Print) / 2754-1177(Online)

© 2024 by the author(s). Licensee EWA Publishing, Oxford, UK. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license. Authors who publish this series agree to the following terms:
1. Authors retain copyright and grant the series right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgment of the work's authorship and initial publication in this series.
2. Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the series's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgment of its initial publication in this series.
3. Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See Open access policy for details).

References

[1]. "Introduction to U.S. Economy: Monetary Policy ", crsreports.congress.gov, (Accessed 4 Jun. 2023).

[2]. "Monetary Policy in China - Cornell University", prasad.dyson.cornell.edu, (Accessed 4 Jun. 2023).

[3]. "China’s Monetary Policy: Institutional Setting, Tools and Challenges", link.springer.com, (Accessed 4 Jun. 2023).

[4]. "Federal Reserve Board - Monetary Policy", federalreserve.gov, (Accessed 5 Jun. 2023).

[5]. "Is China better at monetary policy than America? - The Economist", economist.com, (Accessed 4 Jun. 2023).

[6]. "The non-linear impact of monetary policy on international reserves ...", link.springer.com, (Accessed 4 Jun. 2023).