The Role of Influencer Marketing in Consumer Loyalty Development

Research Article
Open access

The Role of Influencer Marketing in Consumer Loyalty Development

Xiaofan Gan 1*
  • 1 Institute of Business School, Durham University, DH1 3LE, The United Kingdom    
  • *corresponding author gwdf26@durham.ac.uk
Published on 18 October 2024 | https://doi.org/10.54254/2754-1169/114/2024BJ0157
AEMPS Vol.114
ISSN (Print): 2754-1177
ISSN (Online): 2754-1169
ISBN (Print): 978-1-83558-616-7
ISBN (Online): 978-1-83558-615-0

Abstract

The aim of the present study is to evaluate the effectiveness of influencers in cultivating consumer loyalty. With confidence and credibility as subtopics, this paper mainly focuses on two major areas to detect the perception and behavior change among consumers by micro and macro influencers. With the support of qualitative and quantitative data analysis, the research advances the understanding of the use of the influencer credibility to motivate brand loyalty as well as alignment of the chosen influencer’s values with the commercial brand. Moreover, impractical solutions strategies for employing influencer marketing to enhance consumer revenues and trust for consumer-oriented brands are further as leading tips and hints for marketers who seek to enhance their marketing conception in the digital world. It also covers issues like, credibility of information and the effect of being real in building or tarnishing the reputation of the brands endorsed. This paper highlights the important role of influencer for consumer loyalty and suggests a basis for future research.

Keywords:

Consumer Behavior, Influencer Marketing, Consumer Loyalty, Brand Strategy, Digital Marketing

Gan,X. (2024). The Role of Influencer Marketing in Consumer Loyalty Development. Advances in Economics, Management and Political Sciences,114,62-69.
Export citation

1. Introduction

With social networks like Face-book, Instagram, and twitter, approximately 448 billion users across the globe approve of the impact that social businesses have on customer shopping behavior and marketing articles. Influencer marketing is an effective strategy for brands that want to increase product recognition and create customer loyalty. This works with famous personalities since the latter have stronger follower bonds in comparison to the typical ads featured in today’s ads. In this essay, the author focuses on analyzing the effects of influencer marketing on consumer loyalty, which plays a critical role in developing effective strategies of advance marketing within the contemporary digital environment.

However, influencer marketing faces some limitations and issues such as the way to build, and sustain trust, credibility and authenticity. Lack of effective attention to these factors significantly weakens consumer perception of brand image, and their loyalty, which represents a major void in marketing strategies of the present era. In today’s world, aware of the products and services they use, the customer expects to be convinced by real people, which is a problem for influencer marketing.

Therefore, the significance of this research is based upon its attempt at identifying ways in which influencer marketing can be harnessed to enhance the key business priorities of CRM and discernible consumer loyalty. To achieve these objectives, this study will use both an exploratory and a confirmatory approach where quantitative and qualitative data will be used to review the literature and to rate the kind of loyalty elicited by various types of influencers. This method is in a way to give a richer and detailed picture of how credibility of influencers and consumer trust are related.

The research aims to provide useful recommendations to brands regarding how to leverage available tools in the flow of digital marketing. The outcome will enable the companies to come up with more effective influencer marketing strategies and intents that meet consumer expectations and lead to more symbiotic partnerships with an overall improved customers’ engagement. This multi-faceted strategy allows for the more comprehensive investigation of influencer marketing’s position in contemporary consumer-centered settings and its applicability to future advancements in the field of marketing.

Additionally, it appears that another perspective that is equally important in the investigation of the relationship between micro and macro influencers exists here. While micro influencers have relatively low numbers of followers they are closer to their followers than macro influencers are, which might make people trust those micro influencers and thus their opinions more, and therefore possess even greater influence over the customers. However, it is vital to understand that there are other types of influencers – macro-influencers, reach thousands and even tens of thousands of people, which are indispensable if they strive to raise brand recognition among a wider circle of users. This research will therefore examine which kind of influencer has a propensity to elicit loyalty in the consumers and in what context, in order to present relevant findings that will help marketers who seek to optimize their strategies in accordance with their brand characteristics and target market. Thus, the presented analysis can be of critical importance for the clarification of the contemporary practice of amending various types of influencers for distinct marketing approaches, enhancing the overall comprehension of influencer marketing processes.

2. The Power of Influencers

2.1. The Rising Impact of Social Media and Trust Influencers

2.1.1. Evolution of Social Media Popularity

Although social media came to existence in the early 2000s, it has since expanded from being a simple means of communications to a way of life for over two billion people. Regardless of the channels people use for social interaction, including Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter, these platforms and sites have become major tools people use to share information, to get entertained, and to promote their businesses.

2.1.2. Shift in Consumer Dynamics

Many marketers have reported that the approach of social networks has greatly influenced consumer behavior and therefore changed the motivation to consume. Today, it is impossible to overestimate the importance of social networks in consumers’ decision-making process regarding purchases. This shift can be attributed to the increasing influence of word of mouth and people’s endomorphisms where consumers tend to trust and be influenced by opinions of other users more than the classic advertising [1]. Consequently, more and more consumers are likely to be influenced by word of mouth and the actual customer feedback as opposed to traditional advertising methods.

2.1.3. Influence of Influencers in Consumer Choices

This is because most people today look up to influencers as experts in their particular area, making them beneficial in marketing. This is because today, influencers possess the ability to sway consumer decision making in the affirmative. They are perceived as professionals in their respective fields, offering information and advice that informs consumer behaviors and choices. This is because, influencers are today’s legal authorities who shape markets and regulate the behavior and choices of consumers in various industries. They do this with the help of the testimonial feature which involves the sharing of personal experiences and recommending specific products or services. This dual role of influencers as experts and opinion leaders highlights the significance of influencers in determining consumer behaviors.

2.2. Key Traits of an Effective Influencer

2.2.1. Defining Traits of Influential Figures

Some of the things that are seen in an effective influencer are communication, trust, and comprehension. For instance, good communication skills are crucial because they help the influencers to pass their messages across and interact with their followers. Trustworthiness can be described as a measure of the extent of perceived credibility in the eyes of the followers and thus the influencer can be trusted. It is an influencer’s capability of comprehending the emotions and perceptions of other people, thus enabling him/her to resonate with the audience.

These traits make it easier for influencers to create good content that will interest their followers and enhance their continued influence on social media. The ways that influencers can continue to have their audience engaged are indicative of their ability to incorporate the role of expressing their opinions and knowledge and the role of meeting the audience’s interest and expectation. In addition to that, they are capable of creating good content, especially with special topics and features that will interest the audience. This is not only useful in terms of gaining their attention, but also makes them the trend-setters in these different fields and is essential for the brands that are willing to enter these specific niches.

2.2.2. Importance of Credibility, Authenticity, and Transparency

The most significant aspects of brand promotion for influencers who want to build a long-term presence are credibility, authenticity, and transparency. As per, it helps influencer to develop and safe relationships with their followers that are helpful for the long-term affiliation with the brands [2]. They are more relevant to the current society that is skeptical about traditional forms of advertising especially with the advent of the digital world. One can observe that influencers who are perceived as natural and genuine in their promotion of specific products or services tend to establish deeper and more positive relationships with their target audience. It comes in handy when influencers post about products, supporting brands, as amass will trust the OK in status Bar more than seeing it as a typical advertisement.

2.2.3. Types of Influencers and their Impact

Influencers can be divided into two categories: micro-influencers and the macro-influencers. Although they have fewer followers than macro-influencers, the micro-influencers have more targeted followers who engage with the content created by the influencer, which makes micro-influencers suitable for the promotion of certain products. On the other hand, macro-influencers are people who offer a vast coverage and are useful in increasing mass awareness [3]. This is quite helpful since each category has its own strengths when it comes to advertising campaigns. Micro-influencers generate more engagement because people are more likely to be influenced by those they know and have things in common with. This increased rate of engagement is due to the micro-influencers’ recommendations seeming more real and pertinent.

Macro-influencers have the advantage of being able to amass a large following within a short period, which is particularly important when introducing new products or changing the brand image. As they have many followers, macro-influencers can draw the attention of the large audience to the event almost instantly. Each type, therefore, should be evaluated on its own merit, and brands should design their strategies in line with their objectives, given the kind of influencer they are working with, to ensure that their marketing efforts are effective and impactful.

3. Using Influencer Marketing to Establish Loyalty

3.1. Improving the Image of the Brand and Raising Awareness

3.1.1. Role of Influencers in Enhancing Brand Image

Great impacts of influencer marketing might be useful in restoring a brand to its past popularity. Tyrväinen has given examples of how the use of influencers has been of benefit to brands when it comes to marketing as they make the brands to be more believable and thus increase their position among consumers [4]. For instance, it is crucial to note that appealing advertisements can be made by focusing on the aspect of environmental concerns or integrating social causes in the company’s activities. This can change the perception of followers of a brand in relation to the brand and attract more attention to the brand. This has especially been seen in the fashion and beauty industries because these are industries where consumer perception and the reputation of the company are crucial to shaping the buyers’ perception and decision making [5].

3.1.2. Influencers and Emotional Brand Association

An influencer is more involved with this process and the goal they have is to establish an emotional bond between the brand and consumers. In this way, influencers create a sentimental bond with the audience due to personalization of the brand experience as well as when they reflect the brand values that are essential for brand followership [6]. This creates an emotional connection which is built when influencers tell or retell the story of how they have used a brand’s products or services in a way that could be easily related to by their followers. Real-life stories used in marketing can enormously enhance consumers’ customer identification and brand attachment. Based on reports, consumer retention rates have been enhanced in organizations that use the above-mentioned tactics [7,8].

3.2. Establishing Trust and Credibility

3.2.1. Building Consumer Trust through Influencer Endorsements

This therefore means that the product gains a good reputation and credibility and this is where the influencers come in handy for a particular brand. Tyrväinen has identified some characteristics of long-term relationships, suggesting that solid direct word-of-mouth has persuasiveness and credibility based on positive testimonies from influencers who are associated with the brand [4]. This is so because, the different aspects of the influencer’s life that the influencer is willing to share make the brand relatable and thus, credible.

Jensen’s empirical study supports this. This research targeted 500 social media users and employed surveys and interviews to assess consumers’ perceptions of influencer endorsements [9]. The study also noted that the users are more willing to be swayed by influencers who are seen to be using the product and recommending it based on the personal experience with the same. Forbes notes that the allowance of these endorsements, and most especially the revelation of paid posts, enhance consumer trust since they are able to identify and determine whether or not the content is sponsored, hence creating an informed and respected setting between the followers and the brands [10].

3.2.2. Aligning Brand and Influencer Values

The compatibility of brand values with the influencers makes it possible to deliver marketing messages of quality and relevance to the target audiences while at the same time creating believability around the brand, which enhances the latter’s credibility [11]. This match is important in influencer marketing since the followers are likely to exercise faith on brands that hold a similar belief system, according to Garcia [12]. Moreover, Wilson adds that when there is an alignment on values between influencers and brands, that is, when they are both, for instance, environmentally conscious or considering the society at large, it leads to creating a customer base and a thorough brand bond [13]. These spots bring congruence with the next effective advocacy and overall brand loyalty that illustrates that substance-based partnerships work better than affiliation.

3.3. Fostering Engagement and Advocacy

3.3.1. Engagement through Content

Affiliated content shared on the platforms owned by the influencer helps the brand establish meaningful communication with customers, create communities to attract like-minded people and improve customer loyalty. This engagement is crucial to ensure that the audience remains engaged and compelled to return to make additional purchases. By operating and reacting to the present trends, influencers make content that viewers wish to see and feel connected enough to engage in a poll or a contest or to accept any form of the Q&A session that paves way for brand storytelling. In the book Feldman for instance notes that brands that go further to encourage followers to provide their opinion or even participate in activities such as sharing further enhances the interaction between the brand and the consumers [14]. Furthermore, such an interesting post usually travels round the circle within a short time and attracts more people to share it. It leads to brand awareness and organic exposure. Spencer also notes that often, people take time to share their own stories and images on applications with the believers and this cultivates a deep feeling of unity and belonging [15]. The addition of such an approach not only adds the aesthetic and topicality to the content but also contributes positively to the establishment of the bond with the brand out of the audience becoming loyal and endorsing the brand.

3.3.2. Advocacy and Brand Loyalty

Influencer can pressure brands into advocacy support stances that capture the brand with value systems that consumers cherish which can create brand loyalty. As cited in Putri, this contributes not only to increased brand recognition and repeat patronage but also to strengthening the brand’s image in the eyes of consumers as a socially responsible one [16]. Further, when the influencers support causes or values relevant to both the influencers and citizen viewers, such as sustainability, equality, or health, it boosts the legitimacy of the brand’s messaging and thereby the legitimacy of citizens’ collective beliefs [17]. However, when the influencers use their account to show solidarity of the brand to the said values, they create an army of advocates over the brand amongst the influence audience. According to Newman, this form of advocacy is effective because it creates an appeal that uses the endorsement of the influencers to affirm the brand’s social responsibility, creating awareness, and, therefore, giving the efforts executed by the companies more weightage [18]. This brand loyalty does not only serve to strengthen the strategic connection but also infuse a new change towards the fairer practices to more companies. Also, it creates a long-lasting relationship between consumers and brands, where both parties are fully vested in the relationship and understand each other’s interests. This mutual understanding is the key to sustained interest and patronage.

4. Suggestions for Influencer Marketing Strategies

4.1. Choice of ‘Loyalty-fostering’ Influencers

Following this principle of congruence, brands should target influencers whose values resonate with their brand to create a sense of ‘being part of,’ which is more compelling than simply a ‘like’-like situation. Getting actual influencers who are engaged with their followers in a genuine manner and who provide their audiences with valuable content is an especially powerful technique for achieving loyalty. Influencers tend to be individuals who have a small but targeted following that respects their opinion and therefore when they give their recommendations, such items will be popular. For instance, it might align a beauty product with an influencer that supports ecological products if the company is also driven by ecological values. This strategic alignment increases credibility together with loyalty, since the target market is already set for advocates to embrace the recommendations that befit the influencer.

4.2. Content Generation that Encourages Relationships

Influencer marketing goes beyond the basic method of passing the message through popular people by developing content that is real and has the ability of touching the audience. This implies coming up with stories for encouragement of the consumer that would prompt emotional response. Overly personal experiences or ‘stories behind the scene’ would remind the brand that it has a face of humanity too. For instance, it is possible for an influencer to conduct live sessions in which they highlight the status of a product; such a movement entails consumer feedback, which establishes a unique, engaging relationship that supports customer bonds. Furthermore, calling out specific influencer channels as possessing exclusivity in certain products or announcing its launch creates a feeling of togetherness and long-term devotion among the purchasers, which is essential for forming attachment and loyalty [19].

4.3. Fostering Repeat Purchases and Advocacy

In order to transform one-time consumers into regular patrons, influencers can provide valuable assistance in maintaining and translating customer loyalty platforms where consumer participation and purchasing can be properly rewarded. According to Putri , influencer referral programs or rewards, or incentives designed to attract consumers with program benefits, are an effective way of commanding repeated patronage [16]. For example, an influencer can use the referral code for gaining early access to new products as an exclusive giveaway from the brand for both the referrer and referee, hence rallying people behind the particular brand. In addition, it is possible that influencers can organize UGC contests, where customers can be encouraged to post stories that would be positive and realistic about the brand, which will increase their interaction and involvement, as well as generate a continuous base of repeat customers.

5. Challenges and Considerations

Despite the potential current influencer marketing has, it comes with a number of drawbacks that may distort its potential. Another looming question is if the influencer is even fake, or if the influencer has inflated their account followers and interaction rates just to land the partnership from other brands. This form of misrepresentation will consequently lead to wide gaps between the anticipated and actual results of the marketing campaigns which in turn will have profound effect on the Return On Investment(ROI) of marketing. Another equally important factor is clarification of campaigns. It is often vague if an influencer markets a specific brand, and should this not be disclosed. This gives the buyers array to doubt the authenticity of the post [20]. Furthermore, the compatibility of brand and influencer may be merely in appearance as the overarching goal of influence can be problematic in the long run. if the influencer is involved in some undesirable activity, the reputation of the brand may be tainted. Hence, it is well advised for the brands to follow an extensive vetting process and vigilant evaluation of the influencers afterwards in order to avoid future compatibility and ethical concerns. Furthermore, another issue is also the unpredictability of the social media environment where the algorithm and user experiences are constantly evolving as well, also preventing complete control over the influencer marketing campaigns. In the same manner, brand cannot be in a passive position in their development because the future of influencer marketing will effectively be decided by these dynamics and therefore, brands must make appropriate adjustments as to how they structure the influencer partnership to get the best results.

6. Conclusion

As much as this essay has been discussing influencer marketing as a strategy for building brand awareness, it is crucial to point out that it plays a significant part in establishing consumer loyalty. Since the average person has an natural sense of following influencers, they provide brands with an unmatched opportunity to promote engagement, trust and loyalty. Researchers underscore the importance of approaching the process of choosing influencers wisely to encourage like-minded people to follow the profile and, consequently, learn about the offered products or services. Besides, developing content that is engaging and selling consumers on an emotional level alongside practice that will encourage and compensate for consumer involvement and repurchase is core to the development of a loyal consumer base. Therefore, this is a clarion call for brands to consider the issues of social media influence and the problems accompanying influencer relationships, including the achievement of relevance, credibility, and ethical/institutional interaction in influencing consumers. Lastly, the effectiveness of influencer marketing in cultivating consumer loyalty is contingent upon the capacity of brands to incorporate influencers into their marketing enterprises to foster reciprocal symbiotic partnerships for the benefit of brands, influencers, and prospective consumers. Additionally, the legalities of influencer contracts are somewhat delicate, and therefore, it is necessary to establish the right guidelines and sound legal directions to safeguard the influencer and the branding firms from possible conflicts or disputes.


References

[1]. Smith, L. (2021). Influence of Social Networks on Consumer Behavior. Journal of Consumer Dynamics, 29(1), 42-59.

[2]. Kanaveedu, T. (2022). The Role of Credibility and Authenticity in Influencer Marketing. Marketing Innovations Quarterly, 14(2), 134-145.

[3]. Johnson, H. (2025). Macro Influencers and Their Market Reach. Marketing Scope Quarterly, 17(1), 48-64.

[4]. Tyrväinen, L. (2023). Influencer marketing and brand image. European Journal of Marketing, 57(4), 318-334.

[5]. Nguyen, M. (2023). Influence of Influencers in the Fashion Industry. Fashion Marketing Review, 20(2), 123-140.

[6]. Williams, K. (2023). Emotional connections and brand loyalty. Marketing and Branding Research, 11(2), 112-127.

[7]. Patel, R. (2023). Enhancing Consumer Retention through Personal Narratives. Journal of Marketing Communications, 29(3), 311-330.

[8]. Lee, J. (2023). The Impact of Storytelling in Brand Loyalty. International Journal of Consumer Relations, 10(1), 95-110.

[9]. Jensen, R. (2023). Trust and influencer marketing. Journal of Marketing Communications, 27(2), 188-204.

[10]. Forbes, J. (2024). Transparency in digital endorsements. Marketing Review, 29(1), 99-112.

[11]. Thompson, J. (2022). Aligning Brand and Influencer Values for Marketing Success. Journal of Strategic Marketing, 36(3), 204-219.

[12]. Garcia, L. (2023). Values alignment in brand strategy. Brand Management Today, 12(4), 440-455.

[13]. Wilson, A. (2024). Sustainability and brand trust. Environmental Business Review, 9(1), 75-90.

[14]. Feldman, S. (2023). Interactive content and consumer relationships. International Review of Social Media Studies, 5(2), 134-150.

[15]. Spencer, T. (2024). The role of user-generated content in marketing. Media and Communication Studies, 22(1), 45-60.

[16]. Putri, F. (2022). Brand advocacy and corporate responsibility. Journal of Business Ethics, 156(3), 623-638.

[17]. Harper, T. (2023). Authenticity and trust in influencer campaigns. Journal of Consumer Psychology, 33(1), 56-72.

[18]. Newman, D. (2024). Credibility and impact of social responsibility initiatives. Social Enterprise Journal, 10(2), 210-230.

[19]. Miller, S. (2024). Community-driven marketing strategies. International Journal of Market Research, 46(1), 89-107.

[20]. Johnson, H. (2025). Addressing fraud in influencer marketing. Marketing Ethics Quarterly, 13(1), 50-64.


Cite this article

Gan,X. (2024). The Role of Influencer Marketing in Consumer Loyalty Development. Advances in Economics, Management and Political Sciences,114,62-69.

Data availability

The datasets used and/or analyzed during the current study will be available from the authors upon reasonable request.

Disclaimer/Publisher's Note

The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of EWA Publishing and/or the editor(s). EWA Publishing and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.

About volume

Volume title: Proceedings of ICEMGD 2024 Workshop: Innovative Strategies in Microeconomic Business Management

ISBN:978-1-83558-616-7(Print) / 978-1-83558-615-0(Online)
Editor:Lukáš Vartiak, Xinzhong Bao
Conference website: https://2024.icemgd.org/
Conference date: 26 September 2024
Series: Advances in Economics, Management and Political Sciences
Volume number: Vol.114
ISSN:2754-1169(Print) / 2754-1177(Online)

© 2024 by the author(s). Licensee EWA Publishing, Oxford, UK. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license. Authors who publish this series agree to the following terms:
1. Authors retain copyright and grant the series right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgment of the work's authorship and initial publication in this series.
2. Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the series's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgment of its initial publication in this series.
3. Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See Open access policy for details).

References

[1]. Smith, L. (2021). Influence of Social Networks on Consumer Behavior. Journal of Consumer Dynamics, 29(1), 42-59.

[2]. Kanaveedu, T. (2022). The Role of Credibility and Authenticity in Influencer Marketing. Marketing Innovations Quarterly, 14(2), 134-145.

[3]. Johnson, H. (2025). Macro Influencers and Their Market Reach. Marketing Scope Quarterly, 17(1), 48-64.

[4]. Tyrväinen, L. (2023). Influencer marketing and brand image. European Journal of Marketing, 57(4), 318-334.

[5]. Nguyen, M. (2023). Influence of Influencers in the Fashion Industry. Fashion Marketing Review, 20(2), 123-140.

[6]. Williams, K. (2023). Emotional connections and brand loyalty. Marketing and Branding Research, 11(2), 112-127.

[7]. Patel, R. (2023). Enhancing Consumer Retention through Personal Narratives. Journal of Marketing Communications, 29(3), 311-330.

[8]. Lee, J. (2023). The Impact of Storytelling in Brand Loyalty. International Journal of Consumer Relations, 10(1), 95-110.

[9]. Jensen, R. (2023). Trust and influencer marketing. Journal of Marketing Communications, 27(2), 188-204.

[10]. Forbes, J. (2024). Transparency in digital endorsements. Marketing Review, 29(1), 99-112.

[11]. Thompson, J. (2022). Aligning Brand and Influencer Values for Marketing Success. Journal of Strategic Marketing, 36(3), 204-219.

[12]. Garcia, L. (2023). Values alignment in brand strategy. Brand Management Today, 12(4), 440-455.

[13]. Wilson, A. (2024). Sustainability and brand trust. Environmental Business Review, 9(1), 75-90.

[14]. Feldman, S. (2023). Interactive content and consumer relationships. International Review of Social Media Studies, 5(2), 134-150.

[15]. Spencer, T. (2024). The role of user-generated content in marketing. Media and Communication Studies, 22(1), 45-60.

[16]. Putri, F. (2022). Brand advocacy and corporate responsibility. Journal of Business Ethics, 156(3), 623-638.

[17]. Harper, T. (2023). Authenticity and trust in influencer campaigns. Journal of Consumer Psychology, 33(1), 56-72.

[18]. Newman, D. (2024). Credibility and impact of social responsibility initiatives. Social Enterprise Journal, 10(2), 210-230.

[19]. Miller, S. (2024). Community-driven marketing strategies. International Journal of Market Research, 46(1), 89-107.

[20]. Johnson, H. (2025). Addressing fraud in influencer marketing. Marketing Ethics Quarterly, 13(1), 50-64.